Assessing the Content Quality of Online Parental Resources about Newborn Metabolic Disease Screening: A Content Analysis

Abstract

by Olivia M. Y. Ngan,Wing Ki Wong,Janice Ching Tam andChi Kong Li
Int. J. Neonatal Screen. 2022, 8(4), 63; https://doi.org/10.3390/ijns8040063 - 13 May 2023Cited by 2 | Viewed by 2453
Abstract
Parents increasingly utilise the internet to obtain information on health practices, but the quality of online information about screening for inherited metabolic diseases (IMD) needs to be improved. A content analysis examined how IMD blood and urine tests were described online in local healthcare sectors between May and June 2021. Among the nine resources, four were blood test providers and five were urine test providers. All mentioned the test benefits and procedures. Other information, such as false-positive/negative or risk of pain, was infrequently mentioned. The descriptions of urine tests are advertised as outperforming blood tests and can be purchased from commercial laboratory sites without medical guidance. Two urine test providers claimed no false results were reported. A few commercial advertisements highlighted the simplicity of the urine test and potentially overstated the invasiveness of the blood test. We found that some advertisements described IMD as “silent killers” and emphasised the advantage of getting “reassurance” in controlling the child’s developmental health and well-being. To better protect the parents, or broadly, the public interest, regulatory and oversight measures on the urine tests should be implemented to promote the proper use of genetic tests. Without timely regulation and oversight, the incorrect descriptions might create a public misconception about utilising these commercial laboratory tests to inform health decisions. Full article
► Show Figures
15 pages, 288 KiB
Open AccessReview